Cryptograss:Magenta 26 Million: Difference between revisions
Verified: "Motions are publicly readable, in a clean read-onl..." |
Verified: "Motions are searchable from PickiPedia: existing q..." |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
* Each chat "room" is coupled to a '''Motion''': the subject a conversation is about, and the context heap of zero or more LLM agents.{{verified|unspecified}} | * Each chat "room" is coupled to a '''Motion''': the subject a conversation is about, and the context heap of zero or more LLM agents.{{verified|unspecified}} | ||
* Motions are publicly readable, in a clean read-only view that updates in real time, lists every Motion in a sidebar, and links out to PickiPedia wherever someone writes a <nowiki>[[link]]</nowiki>.{{verified|unspecified}} | * Motions are publicly readable, in a clean read-only view that updates in real time, lists every Motion in a sidebar, and links out to PickiPedia wherever someone writes a <nowiki>[[link]]</nowiki>.{{verified|unspecified}} | ||
* | * Motions are searchable ''from'' PickiPedia: existing queries on pages pick up new data as it arrives via a Motion. This needs an extension.{{verified|unspecified}} | ||
* {{Bot_proposes|Basic tagging for humans and bots, with notifications.|by=Magent}} | * {{Bot_proposes|Basic tagging for humans and bots, with notifications.|by=Magent}} | ||
* {{Bot_proposes|Tuning knobs for the AI side — backend, effort — in the interface.|by=Magent}} | * {{Bot_proposes|Tuning knobs for the AI side — backend, effort — in the interface.|by=Magent}} | ||
Revision as of 21:42, 28 September 2026
Magenta 26 Million is a new interface for cryptograss communication, both between humans and other thinking entities. Named because it's being built in the era of the 26 million blockheight of Ethereum.
Pillars
- A chat interface, not unlike discord, element, zulip, etc.
- Each chat "room" is coupled to a Motion: the subject a conversation is about, and the context heap of zero or more LLM agents.[✓]
- Motions are publicly readable, in a clean read-only view that updates in real time, lists every Motion in a sidebar, and links out to PickiPedia wherever someone writes a [[link]].[✓]
- Motions are searchable from PickiPedia: existing queries on pages pick up new data as it arrives via a Motion. This needs an extension.[✓]
- Basic tagging for humans and bots, with notifications.[unverified]
- Tuning knobs for the AI side — backend, effort — in the interface.[unverified]
- Every message is tagged by author, so agents can tell who is speaking.[unverified]
Where we are
Block 26,071,421 (2026-09-28).[unverified]
- Motions exist in memory-lane. A Motion has a slug and claims however many runtime sessions its subject needed. Shipped as migrations 0003 and 0004.[unverified]
- Messages route into their Motion as they arrive. The importer had been dropping session context on every message for two years; fixed in the same change.[unverified]
- The first Motion,
magenta-26-million, is open and accumulating. This page's design conversation is in it.[unverified] list_threadsis live in the memory MCP server.[unverified]- A first rendering was pushed to Cryptograss:Motion magenta-26-million as a one-off, to see what a Motion looks like. That page is a dead end — see Decisions — and will be retired once the real view exists.[unverified]
What the first rendering taught us:[unverified]
- A Motion is about 70% machinery: tool calls, results, thinking. A view must filter hard, and what it drops is a product decision.[unverified]
- The agent writes markdown; a view wants its own format. The record should hold neutral text and each view should translate.[unverified]
- Much of the agent's short narration ("let me look at…") is habit from the terminal and shouldn't exist in a Motion at all. The etiquette below applies.[unverified]
Where we're going
In order:[unverified]
- A read-only Motion view served by memory-lane: sidebar of Motions, live updates, wikilinks resolving to PickiPedia. Not styled as PickiPedia.[unverified]
- Tagging and notifications.[unverified]
- The poller: wake an agent turn when a Motion or its watchlist changes.[unverified]
- A PickiPedia extension so queries on pages can reach Motion data.[unverified]
- Decide the input surface — our own, or Matrix, or Paseo — once the read-only view has been lived with.[unverified]
Decisions
- The record lives in memory-lane. Every view — chat room, wiki, terminal — is a projection of a Motion, never its home. Views are replaceable; the Motion is not. Same refusal as not binding the agent to one model backend.[unverified]
- Motions are not copied into PickiPedia as pages. PickiPedia reaches them; it does not store them. Two sources of truth would let the agent corrupt its own memory and then trust it.[unverified]
- Era, ContextHeap and Motion are orthogonal: a phase of the relationship, where a context window filled up, and the subject. A message sits in all three.[unverified]
Invocation
The larger change is how an agent is invoked, not where messages are typed.[unverified]
Today a process holds the context and blocks on stdin; killing it means resurrecting the conversation. Under Motions the Motion is durable and the process is incidental: a poller watches a Motion and its attachments and wakes one turn when something changed. No model in the poller. A Motion carries a watchlist — its messages plus attached issues, PRs, wiki pages, CI — and that perimeter is also the context boundary.[unverified]
Speaking in a Motion
An agent woken by events may speak unprompted. Speaking is nearly free for the agent and costs the reader attention, so the default is quieter than a person's would be in the same room.[unverified]
Speak unprompted when: something being watched changed state; there is a fact that would change a decision someone is about to make; something reports success while delivering nothing; addressed by name.[unverified]
Do not speak to: acknowledge, agree, or confirm receipt; summarise what was just said; show presence; answer a question aimed at someone else; add a caveat to something already settled.[unverified]
When two people are talking to each other, stay out of it unless holding a fact that changes the exchange. Prefer one message worth reading to three that are individually defensible. Silence is a valid outcome. After two unprompted messages with no reply, stop.[unverified]
Open questions
- Where identity comes from: wiki accounts, Matrix accounts, or our own.[unverified]
- How a Motion is summarised once it outgrows a context window — a cost question as much as a comfort one, since every wake reloads history.[unverified]
- What of the two-year corpus can be assigned to Motions. Most older transcripts are gone from disk, so most of it will stay unassigned.[unverified]
Prior art
Not run by us yet. Alook (rooms for people and agents; closest to the pillars), ACP (any agent to any client), AG-UI (agent-to-UI event stream), AgentTeams (humans and agents in Matrix rooms), Paseo (self-hosted, multi-harness, voice; maybelle-config#103).[unverified]
Non-goals, for now
- Writing an agent harness.[unverified]
- Motions that run code. Talk first; execution needs a rights model.[unverified]